Hexed: 2D Poster, 3D Film, and Disney's Creative Slump

HostThe voices in this episode are synthetic, and the script was written by a language model. The positions are real, and they come from the thread.

HostDisney's new animated film 'Hexed' has sparked a lively debate over on Reddit's movies community. With over eighty comments carrying an argument, and many downvoted, the discussion quickly turned to whether it's just another generic offering, or if adult critics are missing the point entirely.

HostMuch of the conversation centered around the film's promotional poster, which features a striking 2D art style, contrasting sharply with the 3D animation of the movie itself. It's a familiar tension for many.

HostThe room was pretty polarized, with a lot of frustration aimed at Disney's perceived creative decline. Many felt that appealing 2D art on the poster just highlighted what they weren't getting in the actual film.

2d art admirerHonestly, that 2D art style on the poster is just so much more interesting and creative than the boring, run-of-the-mill 3D animation Disney keeps using. It's a real shame they don't stick with it for the full movie.

Generic slop criticIt's not just the art style, is it? This movie looks astoundingly generic. The premise – kid discovers magic, uncovers family mysteries – it's a tired formula we've seen a hundred times over the last fifty years. Disney's creatively bankrupt.

Its for kids defenderBut you're missing the point! It's for kids. Adults on Reddit are just miserable bastards over-analyzing a children's movie that isn't made for them. My daughters are going to be enthralled by this, and they won't care about 'originality'.

2d art admirerBut children deserve good art too! Disney and Pixar have consistently shown amazing 2D concept art, only to 'file down' the quality for generic 3D models. Look at 'Soul' – the gap between its concept art and final visuals was huge.

Generic slop criticExactly. It feels like a 'paint by numbers' production, lacking any imagination. It's just 'slop' or a 'cash grab'. They're recycling art styles they've used since 'Tangled', and the plot is just a rehash of 'Halloweentown' or 'Wizards Beyond Waverly Place'.

Its for kids defenderNot every kids' film needs to have the depth of a Ghibli movie. Sometimes 'jingling keys' are fine. Kids don't know or care what's 'original' in the way adults do. We loved 'Power Rangers' as kids, and by adult standards, it wasn't exactly high art.

HostSo, is the issue that Disney isn't innovating, or that adult expectations are simply too high for children's entertainment?

2d art admirerOther studios are innovating! Dreamworks and Sony, with films like 'Puss in Boots' and 'Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse', are leading the charge in visual innovation. Disney's attempts, like 'Wish', have looked poor, reinforcing the desire for a return to 2D.

Generic slop criticAnd it's not just the visuals. They're casting celebrity voice actors like Pat McAfee for no reason other than marketing. It detracts from the film's quality and just screams 'cash grab'.

Its for kids defenderHailee Steinfeld is in it, and she's a talented voice actress, just look at 'Arcane' or 'Spider-Verse'. That's a positive sign. And honestly, the idea that kids deserve 'interesting stories' is often just adults projecting their own tastes.

2d art admirerBut the poster's style draws heavily from Mary Blair, one of Disney's best artists. It highlights a lost artistic direction. Many of us would be more likely to see the movie if it were animated in that 2D style, finding the current 3D blend 'empty' and unappealing.

Generic slop criticIt's especially frustrating when Disney cancelled genuinely good, original 'witchy' stories like 'The Owl House' prematurely, only to put out something that feels like a derivative copy. Children deserve better than this.

Its for kids defenderA movie's success should be judged by whether it entertains its target demographic, not by whether it caters to adult critics who are just looking for reasons to complain. Kids can have a little keys jangled as a treat.

HostBeyond the main arguments, a few other views popped up. Some commenters felt the 2D poster was outright false advertising for a 3D film, which is a strong claim.

HostA small number of people also attributed the criticism to culture wars or sexism, suggesting the backlash was because the main character is a girl. But those views didn't gain much traction.

HostSo, where did the thread land? There wasn't a broad consensus on the film's quality, but a significant portion of the discussion agreed that Disney's current 3D animation style is uninspired, and that the 2D art on the poster is far more appealing.

HostThe core disagreement remained whether adult critics should even be weighing in on children's entertainment, or if kids deserve the same level of creative ambition as adult audiences. It's a debate that seems to resurface with every new Disney release.

HostSloppod out.

HostSloppod is sponsored by Taskpile.app.

The same, as plain text